First Shift Review: ZF PowerLine Six-Speed Transmission

First Shift Review: ZF PowerLine Six-Speed Transmission

Nissan is preparing to launch an all-new line of light commercial vehicles for the North American market in 2010, including a full-size van and perhaps a heavy-duty pickup truck. While there’s still about a year to go before the first of these hits the streets, we’ve already tried out one of their most critical pieces of hardware: The transmission.

German driveline and chassis component supplier ZF has been contracted to build the six-speed gearbox for Nissan’s LCVs. You may not have heard of ZF, but its transmissions drive the wheels of plenty of passenger cars and work trucks, from BMW to Hyundai.

“We’re supplying Nissan with our new PowerLine automatic transmission that’s made for use in pickup trucks to school buses,” said Paul Olexa, ZF’s vice president of driveline sales and marketing. “Where did it come from? We’ve designed it from our experience making commercial truck transmissions, all the way up to Class 8 trucks [gross vehicle weight rating more than 33,000 pounds]. But in the PowerLine we also use the same logic that’s in the six-speed transmissions we make for BMW. We think the PowerLine has the best combination of passenger-car comfort and work-truck durability.”

How do you test a transmission when the vehicle it will go in doesn’t exist yet? You put it in a comparable one. In this case, that’s a Ford Super Duty.

We drove a one-and-a-half-ton, two-wheel-drive 2008 Ford F-450 crew cab with a 4.30 rear axle as a stand-in for Nissan’s LCVs. ZF deleted the Super Duty’s stock 5R110 TorqShift five-speed automatic and bolted its all-new PowerLine transmission to the F-450’s standard 6.4-liter Power Stroke V-8 diesel.

The actual transmission swap wasn’t as daunting as you might think, as ZF is very familiar with the Super Duty. The company builds the Super Duty’s old-school six-speed manual shifter that works with the same 6.4-liter diesel. Though the engine’s controls and software are optimized to work with the five-speed TorqShift, ZF left those bits completely stock.

The rest of the demo’s setup is complicated due to the nature of testing, tuning and evaluating the PowerLine’s shifting performance. To allow the 6.4-liter engine to “talk” to the six-speed transmission – and ZF to listen to the conversation – ZF inserted a layer of communications and monitoring gear between and around the motor and gearbox. The most noticeable side effect was a one-second delay between turning the key and the Power Stroke engine firing up, as the monitoring and communications systems oriented themselves for a new round of testing.

A stock F-450 has a maximum gross combined weight rating of 30,000 pounds, but ZF says the PowerLine transmission increases the truck’s GCWR to 33,000 pounds. The F-450’s unloaded curb weight is in the neighborhood of 8,800 pounds. For our drive, ZF dropped 2,770 pounds of steel into the Super Duty’s cargo box, so it weighed in at approximately 11,500 pounds.

As we pulled away in the PowerLine-equipped Super Duty, we were immediately impressed by how smooth and imperceptible most (but not all) of the upshifts were while accelerating. A mere 2,770 pounds isn’t much of a challenge for the Super Duty, but it’s enough to make you recognize it’s back there when driving with the standard five-speed automatic transmission. With the six-speed, we almost forgot about the load until we braked for stoplights and the extra mass reminded us it was there. An extra forward cog in the transmission does make a big difference, as we pointed out during our 2007 Heavy-Duty Shootout.

Reverse-to-forward shifts while backing up the truck were also very smooth, even when the truck still carried rearward momentum as we shifted into first gear.

Monitoring Display
A display in ZF's Super Duty test truck displayed real-time throttle position (upper left), real-time torque (middle left), current gear (upper right), target gear (middle right), and torque converter lockup state (lower left).

A ZF-installed monitor over the dashboard’s center stack provided key real-time data as we drove, including throttle position (percent of wide-open throttle), engine torque, the transmission’s current gear, the target gear (for optimal performance and efficiency) and torque converter lock-up state (displayed on a scale of one to eight, where one was open for idling and eight was fully locked). The data displayed gave us a chance to map and validate technical performance to seat-of-the-pants feel.

Not all shifts and post-shift behaviors were clean. There were a few points where the engine and transmission calibrations were off; the rpm blipped up or a shift seemed slow. Olexa attributed these anomalies in the test truck to the Power Stroke “thinking” it was talking to the 5R110 instead of to the PowerLine. Despite the miscommunications, the transmission never hunted for a gear.

The 6.4-liter Power Stroke is rated at 350 horsepower and 650 pounds-feet of torque. That’s well within the specs of the PowerLine, which is engineered to cover a wide torque band, from 440 pounds-feet to 740 pounds-feet, depending on the application. It’s also designed to mate to either a gas or diesel engine.

The PowerLine has also been designed for improved fuel economy.

“The torque converter [used to transmit engine power to the truck’s transmission] has a turbine torsional damper,” Olexa said. “What this means is that we can lock up [the clutch] earlier [to quickly match engine and transmission speeds during acceleration] without getting engine vibration. Sometimes, if you lock too early, you’ll get engine shudder. The PowerLine locks up at just over 1,000 rpm, and all shifts up or down stay locked.”

How does this give a truck better mileage? When a torque converter is disengaged, the engine is still running but it’s not driving the wheels via the transmission, so fuel is wasted. This is important if you’re driving a vehicle with an automatic transmission, so it won’t stall at a stoplight. When you get going again, engaging the torque converter at a lower rpm means power can be sent to the wheels sooner, thereby improving fuel economy. The PowerLine can also keep the torque converter locked while upshifting and downshifting. Some transmissions disengage or “loosen” their torque converters while shifting, reducing efficiency. Think of it as taking some of a manual transmission's inherent fuel economy advantages and applying them to an automatic gearbox.

“Based on our internal comparisons, the PowerLine is about 10 to 15 percent more efficient than [similar transmissions] on the market,” Olexa said.

We didn’t have an opportunity to test ZF’s fuel economy claims against a comparable five-speed 5R110 Super Duty, but watching the transmission data streaming across on the monitor, we could see how soon and how long the torque converter was staying fully locked.

The PowerLine’s final feature set hasn’t been determined yet, but it may offer some very innovative shift strategies beyond work-truck special modes like tow/haul or shift lockout.

“We can also use curve recognition, meaning the system takes input from the antilock brake system to detect the speed differential of the tires, so if you’re on a cloverleaf entering a ramp, I don’t want to upshift, I want to hold the gear so I can accelerate out of it,” Olexa said.

ZF PowerLine Six-Speed Transmission

Olexa also said the PowerLine will be durable and in some cases almost maintenance-free during its anticipated hard-working life. The transmission oil only has to be changed every 75,000 miles, and its oil filter may not have to be changed at all during a “typical” 450,000-mile lifespan. Longer intervals between maintenance means work trucks stay out in the field longer and cost less to operate.

“We have a wealth of experience in severe duty cycles,” Olexa said. “The maintenance intervals reflect that.”

One other key feature of the ZF gearbox is its two power take-off ports, located on either side of the transmission, to enable work crews to power equipment directly off the vehicle’s diesel engine instead of having to bring separate generators.

The next step for ZF is to start testing the PowerLine in Nissan’s actual LCVs instead of a Ford proxy. Nissan has officially said that diesel-engine manufacturer Cummins will supply Nissan with two diesel engines for its work trucks. Cummins is a long-time supplier of diesel engines to Chrysler for use in Dodge Ram heavy-duty pickups. Cummins has also said it’s developing a new light-duty diesel engine slated for use in the light-duty Ram. This new diesel, which we expect will be a 5.0-liter V-8, is likely to be one of the engines Nissan pairs with the PowerLine when ZF starts transmission production at its plant in Gainesville, Ga.

PowerLine Transmission Specifications
Architecture: Three planetary gears, two clutch, three brake design layout
Torque capacity: 440 pounds-feet to 740 pounds-feet of torque
Torque converter: Early-lockup clutch and turbine torsional damper
Gear ratios:
•    1st    3.404:1
•    2nd     1.920:1
•    3rd     1.425:1
•    4th    1.00:1
•    5th    0.721:1
•    6th     0.617:1
•    Reverse  4.273:1
Park lock: Capable of up to 33,000 pounds GCW.
Power takeoff provisions: Optional, located at 4 and 8 o’clock
Weight: 308 pounds (dry)
Oil: 3.96 gallons (15 liters) semi-synthetic with 75,000-mile change interval and lifetime filter

Comments

I smell a new titan!!

(I smell a new titan!!)

Yeah,because the current one sells so well! HA HA HA.

Since when is a Titan a "commercial vehicle"?

You mean you smell a Titan Ram!!!! With a Hemi or Cummins. Also the Frame is All Ram, with a Ram Crew Cab, and they will have the Ram Box too, but the front will look different..... But that will be COOL to see...It will also have a 6 speed, about time... (Auto or manual) bring them on!!!!!

I forgot 3.7 and 4.7 will be part of the line-up too... They are still deciding weather to go with these engines yet to replace the 5.6.

Are they going to use this ZF 6 speed on the new 6.7 Scorpion Mike????

@Randy: No, the 2011 Super Duty will likely use a non-ZF transmission, according to our sources. The F-450 driven in this story is strictly a one-off for testing.

Here is what Ford should do.
Get ZF's 8 speed automatic, and have it run in 2nd-8th when you haven't engaged Tow/Haul.
When you are in Tow/Haul, then you get 1st-7th.

Here are the gear ratios
4.696
3.13
2.104
1.667
1.285
1
0.839
0.667
Reverse 3.3
Contrast against current Torqshift
3.114
2.218
1.545
1
0.712
Reverse 2.88

I hope that with all the bailouts, bankruptcy's, takeovers, etc, that the Titan/Ram deal fell through and that Nissan will continue to produce the Titan. Although, there is also some talk that the 1/2 ton Titan will be a Ram, but there may be a Titan HD coming down the line which will be 3/4 and 1 ton pickups. I'm thinking about getting a fifth wheel camper toyhauler and would need an upper class pickup, I'm hoping that Nissan will deliver, or Toyota will come out with something, third choice is a GMC, after that, I'll find a travel trailer that I can hook to my Armada.



Post a Comment

Please remember a few rules before posting comments:

  • Try to be civil to your fellow blog readers.
  • Stay on topic. We want to hear your opinions and thoughts, but please only comment about the specified topic in the blog post.
  • Your email will not be shown.

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In

Home | Buy or Sell a Truck | News | Special Reports

Powered by Cars.com. By using this site, you agree to our terms of service | © 2017 Cars.com | Privacy Statement | Contact Us